23/04/2023
The best time to plant a tree was twenty years ago.
The next best time is now. (proverb)
My father in his old age planted oak and beech trees. He was a simple man, of peasant background, his education cut short by poverty and war. Yet, uncommon for most farmers of that time and place he had a love of wild things, and an intuitive understanding of the importance of biodiversity before that word was invented. So wherever a bit of the commercial pine monoculture he had inherited was felled, and on some fields at the edge of forest, he planted mixed woodland. He knew he would be dead before those trees reached maturity and that even his children would not see them fully grown, but they were not for him, nor for us.
This was cathedral thinking, and we need more of it in our approach to nature in order to confront climate change, loss of biodiversity and mass extinction. The polar opposite of a short-term, egocentric approach, cathedral thinking takes a long view and dares to have faith in a future where one’s work may be carried on by others, just as the craftsmen of the great cathedrals knew that they would never see the finished building, nor could be sure that it would ever be completed, but kept building nonetheless.
We should have started a long time ago, planted that proverbial tree twenty, fifty years ago, moved away from deforestation, pesticides, industrial farming. But that is no reason to give up hope and not do it now. Some of the environmental damage and loss of natural habitat we have today are happening because twenty or fifty years ago people thought it was already too late. And so it continues, in a fatalistic downward spiral of unstoppable doom.
When it comes to re-wilding and re-establishing biodiversity, we need cathedral thinking. The forester and writer Peter Wohlleben (‘The secret life of trees’) advocates a radical approach: leave nature alone wherever possible, even if this means that things may get worse for a time before they get better. Don’t plant trees but let saplings grow naturally from seed, for those have a stronger root-system, will be more attuned with each other and better equipped for their changing environment. This is of course a much slower, more unpredictable process than an interventionist, managed program of replanting, even one based on the best of today’s knowledge. It is a leap of faith in the regenerative, self-regulating forces of nature.
The Bavarian Forest national park is part of the largest natural forest region in central Europe. Following a devastating storm in 1983, it was decided to leave it completely without human interference so that it would revert to a primeval forest for future generations. When a severe spruce bark beetle infestation decimated its mature trees in the 1990s there were local protests against this policy and even a court case against the Bavarian state. The court decided in favour of non-interference, and the forest died. Now, 30 years on, it has regenerated from seedlings, with a more varied, natural mix of trees, better able to withstand parasites and climate change. Biodiversity has increased manifold in the same period. Ecological benefits aside, the forest now generates many times more revenue and employment through ecotourism and education programmes than it ever did when still commercially used.
That same bark beetle has now reached the UK and is a serious potential threat to commercial spruce monocultures in Ireland. I see that official advice to forestry owners is to be vigilant and spray insecticide at the first sign of infestation, but this will be a losing battle. It’s time to ditch the monocultures and the poison.
And at home, on our little patch of garden? We can leave things alone more. Where possible, clean up less, maybe fight ‘pests’ less, in the hope and knowledge that somewhere down the line it will all balance out. Not seed wildflower meadows, but if there is space, leave one area of grass alone. The native wildflowers will come, and yes, many are what we have been conditioned to think of as w**ds. There is no difference. Instead of putting up nesting boxes, allow patches of dense, wild shrubbery, and dead wood that is a habitat for insects. The birds will come and build their own nests. Difficult as it is, we need to change our thinking, and our sense of aesthetics around gardening, interfere less and check our urge to improve and design the natural environment the way we would our living rooms.
I go and look at my father’s trees occasionally, and they are still growing. I will not live to see them at their full mature height, and they may never reach it. With climate change reducing precipitation, those old native trees may largely die out anyway. But in their shelter I can see saplings of other, self-seeded trees – robinia, field maple, some forms of ash – which can withstand drought better. Maybe his grandchildren will have inherited a bit of my father’s cathedral thinking and leave them alone to mature. Not for themselves, of course, but for the future.
“There is hope, endless hope, but not for us.”
(Kafka, probably)
P Wohlleben's book is well worth reading: https://www.dubraybooks.ie/product/hidden-life-of-trees-pb-9780008218430
and if in Bavaria or the Czech Republic, this place is worth visiting:
https://www.nationalpark-bayerischer-wald.bayern.de/english/nature/index.htm