Rusty Sugar

Call Website Contact the business

Rusty Sugar Antique, Vintage, Artisan & Modern Decor and Gifts - Nashville, Indiana Introducing Rusty Sugar, a quaint new shop in Nashville, Indiana.
(1)

Nestled within Antique Alley, we celebrate the art of mixing the old with the new!

Antique, vintage, artisan, and modern pieces are carefully curated to create an enchanting blend of nostalgia and style that exudes charm and character.

Each item has its own story to tell, radiating a sense of comfort and familiarity that'll make you feel right at home.

While exploring town, stop by and wander through our collection – who knows what hidden treasures you'll discover!

Follow our journey on Facebook for sneak peeks, giveaways, and behind-the-scenes fun at Rusty Sugar.

11/03/2026

A trip to Brown County Indiana yielded several bags of goodies, and a whole lot more ideas for the future! Make sure to follow and comment BAG CHARM if you want to be the first to know about what’s new! Special shout out to Mulberry Cottage for having some of the most adorable find that scratch my fabric-touching itch! And a special shout-out to Rusty Sugar for having some of the best items and price$ I’ve ever seen in a tourist area! And double thanks for the special mustard seed from Israel. It has earned its place in my decorative shelf in my sewing studio. 🥰

11/03/2026

✨✨TWO ANNOUNCEMENTS!!✨✨
1️⃣ I’m a new consignment partner with Rusty Sugar in Nashville, IN!! 48 of my sweet Shabby Scripture Charms are currently making their way to the shop right now.
2️⃣ I’ve decided to open a shop on Instagram! Items will also be up for sale on Facebook as well. I’m starting here for now instead of Etsy to see how things go and also to cut down on extra fees. I will be sharing some posts in the coming weeks with how the online shop will work and I’ll be adding products as I am able! Comment FIRST IN LINE for something special!
❓ What would you like to see offered in my shop? I’m currently thinking of selling the tags that I’ve used for my charms on printed sheets of fabric for sale as well as other printables on fabric so all you have to do is cut and use, the Shabby Scripture Charms, and some upcycles as I rescue items and give them new life and purpose.
I’m so thrilled for these announcements! Please follow for more shop updates and follow along as I continue working on my other quilt projects.

It’s funny how things work sometimes...Back in May, life threw me a bit of a curveball. For a few months, I wasn’t able ...
11/02/2026

It’s funny how things work sometimes...

Back in May, life threw me a bit of a curveball. For a few months, I wasn’t able to be at the shop as much as I normally would, and I had to make some changes pretty quickly.

One of those was taking a leap and hiring someone to take weekends for me. I’ll admit, it made me nervous. I didn’t know how long I could sustain the extra help or exactly how everything was going to work. I just knew I couldn’t do it all myself anymore.

Fast forward to November…

Peyton and Holly are now helping me at the shop, we’ve found a rhythm that works, and this little place I was worried about keeping open managed to be OPEN 30 OUT OF 31 DAYS IN OCTOBER. 🥹

And what an October it was! So many new visitors. Familiar faces coming back. New friendships. Growth. And so many little moments of pure joy.

So… we’re going to try it again. Rusty Sugar will remain OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK through November!

Monday — 11–4
Tuesday — 11–4
Wednesday — 11–4
Thursday — 10–5
Friday — 10–5
Saturday — 10–5
Sunday — 10–4

There’s something about looking back at a decision you were scared to make and realizing you didn’t actually need to know how it would all work out. Sometimes you just take the next step, trust, and figure out the rest as you go. And somehow… it’s working. 💚

To every person who walked through our door, told someone about us, shared a post, bought something, came back again or simply encouraged us — THANK YOU. We are having so much fun! You are allowing this little shop to keep showing up and for a small business, that really is a very big deal.

Here’s to November!
Let’s see what happens next.


Antique Alley I Love Brown County

10/29/2026
10/28/2026

💚 ...

Old things. New things. Things with a story. Things that make you giggle. Things that remind you of someone. Things root...
10/21/2026

Old things. New things. Things with a story. Things that make you giggle. Things that remind you of someone. Things rooted in faith.

Over the past few weeks we've been moving, rearranging, unpacking and tweaking nearly every little corner of the shop.And somewhere along the way, I feel like Rusty Sugar has become more Rusty Sugar than it's ever been. 💚

A little vintage. A little woodland. A little quirky. A whole lot of heart and faith... and always something tucked around the corner waiting to be discovered. If you're visiting Nashville this fall, wander a little farther off the beaten path and come find us in Antique Alley.

You never know what you'll find. 🍄


I Love Brown County

Thrifting therapy is a real thing...
10/20/2026

Thrifting therapy is a real thing...

Don't mind me today... I'm just over here playing with the new   I brought in today... thought I'd throw it back to an O...
10/18/2026

Don't mind me today... I'm just over here playing with the new I brought in today... thought I'd throw it back to an OG fidget toy this round.

I always have one rule... should someone choose to take one home with them, they have to give it a name - can't wait to hear the names for these!


Antique Alley

Address

ANTIQUE Alley/81 S Jefferson St, Bldg B
Nashville, IN
47448

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 4pm
Tuesday 11am - 4pm
Wednesday 11am - 4pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 10am - 4pm

Telephone

+18122692571

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Rusty Sugar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Rusty Sugar:

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby home improvement businesses