Modest Midwest Wax Co.

Directions Website

Modest Midwest Wax Co. 🌱 American Grown Soy Wax | Clean Burning | Dye-Free
Hand Poured | Small Batch
📍New Castle, IN
📦 Free Delivery & In-Store Pickup

POV: you’re not emotionally ready to give up fall just yet. 🍂🤎 And honestly? Same.There are still a few leaves hanging o...
11/10/2026

POV: you’re not emotionally ready to give up fall just yet. 🍂🤎 And honestly? Same.

There are still a few leaves hanging on the trees, crisp mornings to enjoy, and plenty of time to romanticize the season a little longer. So we’re not saying goodbye just yet. We’re just making your favorite fall scents a little easier to stock up on!

🕯️ 8 oz candles are 43% OFF (just $8!)
🚗 Car diffusers are 40% OFF (just $6!)

Shop our FALL FAVORITES SALE at modestmidwestwaxco.com 🤎

While supplies last.

This was our booth at The Mercantile in Pendleton before you guys absolutely RAVAGED it yesterday. 😂Not sure if I should...
11/08/2026

This was our booth at The Mercantile in Pendleton before you guys absolutely RAVAGED it yesterday. 😂

Not sure if I should be proud or a little concerned about how much restocking I have ahead of me. Send coffee. And maybe an extra set of hands. 😅

Between The Mercantile and The Good Co., yesterday was a REALLY good day. We saw so many familiar faces, met new customers, and watched you guys shop the heck out of our little corners.

Seriously, thank you. We love seeing you love what we make. Now excuse us while we go get busy making more. ❤️

Christmas at The Good Co. ❤️It’s days like today that remind me how lucky I am to do what I love. And having a place lik...
11/07/2026

Christmas at The Good Co. ❤️

It’s days like today that remind me how lucky I am to do what I love. And having a place like The Good Co. be part of that journey makes it even more special.

The Good Co. opened its doors in 2023, and we’ve been here for every Christmas open house since! Hard to believe this is already our fourth. It’s been so much fun being part of these days and seeing the shop come together for the holidays.

If you’re out and about today, stop in and take a look around! There’s plenty to browse, hot cocoa, cookies, and treats from the one and only The Boujie Baker 🎄

Two Christmas open houses. Two locations. One very busy candle maker. 😂🎄Tomorrow we’re celebrating Christmas at BOTH of ...
11/06/2026

Two Christmas open houses. Two locations. One very busy candle maker. 😂🎄

Tomorrow we’re celebrating Christmas at BOTH of our retail homes!

🤍 The Good Co. | New Castle
11 AM – 6 PM

❤️ The Mercantile | Pendleton
11 AM – 7 PM

We’re incredibly grateful for these two shops, the people behind them, and everyone who continues to show up and shop small. It means more than you know.

Can’t make it out tomorrow? You can always shop online at www.modestmidwestwaxco.com

Hope to see you out and about! ❤️

Tomorrow. 🎄Our Christmas Collection is making its way to the website! Tonight I’ll be putting the finishing touches on e...
11/05/2026

Tomorrow. 🎄

Our Christmas Collection is making its way to the website! Tonight I’ll be putting the finishing touches on everything and getting all five scents ready for you to shop online tomorrow.

One of my favorite parts of owning a small business is getting to bring an idea to life, but there’s so much that happens behind the scenes before you ever see the finished product.

From creating the scents and writing descriptions to designing labels, photographing products, creating graphics, and getting everything ready for the website, every little detail takes time.

And that’s just one collection.

There’s no big team behind the scenes. It’s just us, wearing all the hats, putting in the hours, and pouring so much of ourselves into this little business.

Sometimes things take longer than we’d like, but that’s part of doing it all ourselves. And honestly, we wouldn’t have it any other way.

We’re so thankful for everyone who shops small, supports what we do, and continues to show up for our little business. It truly means a lot. ❤️

🎄 Our Christmas Collection arrives online TOMORROW!

Shop: modestmidwestwaxco.com

Before the ornaments, before the presents, before Christmas morning, there was the tree. The yearly trip to find it, the...
11/01/2026

Before the ornaments, before the presents, before Christmas morning, there was the tree. The yearly trip to find it, the smell of fresh-cut pine, and the familiar mess of needles left behind once it made its way into the house. Some traditions never get old. ❤️

Meet The Perfect Tree, the final scent in our nostalgic Christmas collection. 🎄

The entire collection is now available at The Mercantile in Pendleton, open 7 days a week, 11–7. Stop by, smell them for yourself, and find your favorite!

Remember when waking up to a fresh snowfall felt like the most magical thing in the world? Looking out the window to see...
11/01/2026

Remember when waking up to a fresh snowfall felt like the most magical thing in the world? Looking out the window to see everything covered in white, trees sparkling in the morning light, and the excitement of knowing you might get to spend the whole day outside. Snow days just hit different when you were little. ❤️

Meet Snow Day, inspired by the winters we wish we could experience all over again.

❄️ Now available at The Mercantile in Pendleton, open 7 days a week, 11–7. 🎄

Christmas, but make it 1995. ❤️🎄Our Christmas Collection is officially at The Mercantile in Pendleton!Stop in, shop smal...
11/01/2026

Christmas, but make it 1995. ❤️🎄

Our Christmas Collection is officially at The Mercantile in Pendleton!

Stop in, shop small, and get a little nostalgic. Open 7 days a week, 11–7. ❤️

When you’re little, you don’t need much to make Christmas feel magical. A living room full of decorations, presents you ...
10/30/2026

When you’re little, you don’t need much to make Christmas feel magical. A living room full of decorations, presents you can’t wait to open, and a Christmas tree you could stare at for hours. You didn’t know it then, but those ordinary evenings would become some of your favorite memories. ❤️

Meet Twinkling Lights, the next scent in our nostalgic Christmas collection. It will be available this Sunday, and we can’t wait for you to experience it. 🎄

If you grew up with Christmas cookies cooling on the counter and Christmas music playing in the background, this one’s f...
10/30/2026

If you grew up with Christmas cookies cooling on the counter and Christmas music playing in the background, this one’s for you. ❤️

Address

1308 Broad Street, IN 47362
New Castle, IN
47362

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 6pm
Thursday 11am - 6pm
Friday 11am - 6pm
Saturday 11am - 6pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Modest Midwest Wax Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby home improvement businesses